How to Switch Music Services Without Losing Your Library

The catalogue is never what makes switching hard. It is the decade of playlists, the liked songs, and the recommendations that finally understood you. Here is how to move without losing the parts that matter.

Published Updated

Switching services is not a single action, it is a migration with a natural order. Doing it in the wrong order is what makes people give up and go back.

First, know what cannot come with you

Being honest about this up front saves a lot of frustration later.

Playlists

Transfers
Usually
Reality
Track by track, with some matching losses.

Track order within playlists

Transfers
Usually
Reality
Preserved by most importers.

Liked or saved songs

Transfers
Sometimes
Reality
Depends on what permissions the importer requests.

Listening history

Transfers
Rarely
Reality
Some services let you download your play history as a data export, but few apps can import it.

Recommendations quality

Transfers
No
Reality
It is derived from history, so it rebuilds rather than transfers. Expect a few weeks.

Followed artists

Transfers
Sometimes
Reality
Often easier to redo manually than to transfer.

Offline downloads

Transfers
No
Reality
Always tied to the service that issued them.

The order that works

  1. 1

    Do not cancel anything yet

    Run both services in parallel for at least a month. A migration you can abandon is a migration you will actually attempt.

  2. 2

    Audit before you move

    You almost certainly have far fewer playlists that matter than playlists that exist. Identify the ten you actually open. Moving those well beats moving two hundred badly.

  3. 3

    Save liked songs into a playlist

    Most importers request playlist access rather than saved-track access, so liked songs stranded outside a playlist will not travel. Do this before you start.

  4. 4

    Import in batches, checking results

    Import a few playlists, look at the match rate, and adjust expectations before doing the rest. A poor match rate on your particular taste is worth discovering early.

  5. 5

    Fix the important gaps only

    Repair unmatched tracks in the playlists you use. Leave the rest — you will find you do not miss them.

  6. 6

    Seed the new profile deliberately

    Spend the first fortnight playing your genuine favourites rather than testing the catalogue with random searches. The profile learns from what you play, and search queries you never listen to teach it nothing.

  7. 7

    Then decide

    After a month you will know whether the catalogue covers your listening and whether the recommendations have caught up. Cancel at that point, not before.

Testing the catalogue properly

The catalogue question is the one that actually determines whether a switch is viable, and most people test it badly — by searching for a few famous artists, all of which will be present everywhere.

Test with the awkward parts of your library instead:

  • The most obscure artist you play regularly.
  • Non-English releases, if you listen to any — regional catalogue coverage varies enormously between services.
  • Anything genuinely old, where reissues and licensing get complicated.
  • Live albums, remixes and soundtracks, which are the most commonly missing categories.
  • One full discography for an artist you care about, checking for the album that always seems to be absent.

If those all come through, the mainstream catalogue certainly will. If they do not, you have learned it now rather than three weeks after cancelling.

What to check on the new service beyond catalogue

  1. Does it run properly on the devices you actually use? Web, phone, whatever you listen on at work.
  2. Are playback preferences you rely on available — crossfade, gapless, volume normalisation?
  3. Can you see your own listening data for the period you care about, or only a fixed recap?
  4. What is free versus paid, and what does the free tier actually restrict?
  5. Can you organise a large library — folders, pinning, ordering — or is it a flat list?

On Melodius specifically: everything is free with no premium tier, it runs on the web and as an Android app, playback preferences are per account, full listening statistics are available for any period you choose, and the library supports folders and pinning. The catalogue is sourced from third-party providers, so it is worth running the awkward-artist test above before committing.

Running two services without it being miserable

  • Pick one as primary for everyday listening from day one. Splitting your listening between two profiles means neither ever learns you.
  • Keep the old one for the specific things the new one lacks, rather than for general use.
  • Give it a month, then make a decision. An indefinite parallel period is just paying twice.

When you are ready to move playlists, the Spotify import guide covers what the process actually does and why some tracks fail to match.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best way to switch music streaming services?

Run both in parallel for about a month. Move the playlists you actually use, save liked songs into a playlist first so they transfer, seed the new profile by playing your genuine favourites, and only cancel the old service once the catalogue and recommendations have proved themselves.

Can I transfer my listening history to a new service?

Usually not in any useful way. Some services let you download your play history as a data export, but most new services, Melodius included, do not import it, and recommendation quality cannot be moved at all. Both rebuild over the first few weeks of real listening.

How long does it take for a new service's recommendations to get good?

Typically a few weeks of regular listening. You can speed it up by playing your actual favourites early rather than testing the catalogue with searches you never listen to, since only plays teach the profile anything.

How do I check whether a service has the music I listen to?

Search for the awkward parts of your library rather than famous artists — your most obscure regular, non-English releases, old catalogue, live albums and remixes. Those are where catalogues actually differ.

More on this topic

// Topic

Getting started, switching and importing playlists

Set up Melodius on Android, desktop and the web, and move a library across without losing what matters.