Audio Quality Explained: Bitrate, Codecs and Lossless
Streaming services compete on numbers: 320 kbps, 24-bit, 192 kHz. Some of those numbers change what you hear and some only change the file size. Here is how to tell which is which.
Every song you stream is a compressed file chosen by the service, sent over a network, decoded by your device and, very often, re-encoded for Bluetooth before it reaches your ears. Quality can be lost at each step, and the weakest step decides what you hear.
Bitrate, in one paragraph
Bitrate is how much data is used per second of audio, measured in kilobits per second (kbps). Uncompressed CD audio is 16-bit samples, 44,100 of them per second, for two channels: about 1,411 kbps. Streaming formats use far less by throwing away information the encoder judges you will not miss. Higher bitrate means less thrown away, up to the point where nothing audible is left to recover.
Lossy and lossless
- Lossy (MP3, AAC, Ogg Vorbis, Opus)
- Removes detail permanently, guided by models of what human hearing ignores. Modern codecs such as AAC and Opus are much more efficient than MP3, so the same bitrate sounds better than it did fifteen years ago.
- Lossless (FLAC, ALAC)
- Compresses like a zip file: smaller than the original, but decoded back to exactly the same samples. CD-quality lossless is 16-bit at 44.1 kHz.
- Hi-res lossless
- Lossless at higher resolution than CD, usually 24-bit and sometimes 96 or 192 kHz. Useful in mastering; the audible benefit at home is debated, and many phones and computers need an external converter to play the highest sample rates natively.
What you can actually hear
In careful blind comparisons, well-encoded lossy audio at around 256 kbps is very hard for most listeners to tell apart from lossless on most material. Differences show up first in demanding passages, such as cymbals, applause and dense reverb, and on revealing headphones in a quiet room. Below about 128 kbps the gap becomes easy to hear, especially as smeared treble.
That does not make lossless pointless. It removes a variable, and if you have good wired gear and listen closely, it is worth having. But it is rarely the first upgrade that matters.
What the big services stream
Spotify
- Free
- Up to about 160 kbps in the apps; AAC 128 kbps on the web player
- Paid
- Up to about 320 kbps; AAC 256 kbps on the web player
- Lossless
- Premium, up to 24-bit/44.1 kHz FLAC
Apple Music
- Free
- No free tier
- Paid
- AAC, with lossless opt-in
- Lossless
- ALAC from 16-bit/44.1 kHz, Hi-Res up to 24-bit/192 kHz, included
Deezer
- Free
- 64 or 128 kbps MP3
- Paid
- Up to 320 kbps MP3
- Lossless
- Paid plans, FLAC at 1,411 kbps (CD quality)
YouTube Music
- Free
- Normal, up to 128 kbps
- Paid
- Premium chooses up to 256 kbps
- Lossless
- Not offered
Melodius
- Free
- Standard streaming quality from the source provider
- Paid
- No paid tier
- Lossless
- Not offered
Melodius is in that table on purpose. It is a free, independent service without a quality selector or a lossless option, and if fidelity is the main thing you care about, a paid service with lossless is the better choice. What Melodius puts its effort into is the playback side: an equalizer, normalization and crossfade, which change what you hear on any pair of headphones.
Upgrades in order of what you will notice
- Headphone fit and placement. A proper seal on earbuds changes bass more than any setting can.
- The headphones themselves. Frequency response differs enormously between models, far more than between 256 kbps and lossless.
- An equalizer tuned to them. See the equalizer settings guide for a method that takes ten minutes.
- Consistent loudness. Turning on volume normalization stops you comparing songs that are simply mastered louder.
- A wired connection, then lossless. Only once everything above is sorted does the source format become the limiting factor.
Settings worth checking on any service
- Data saver or automatic quality quietly lowers bitrate on mobile data. Turn it off on Wi-Fi if you notice dull treble.
- Download quality is often a separate setting from streaming quality.
- Bluetooth codec can usually be seen in Android's developer options or your headphones' app.
- Equalizers stacked on top of each other, in the phone, the headphone app and the music app, make any one of them hard to judge. Use one and leave the others flat.
Frequently asked questions
What bitrate is good enough for music?
For most people on most headphones, well-encoded AAC or Opus at around 256 kbps is very hard to tell apart from lossless. Below about 128 kbps the loss becomes easy to hear, mainly as smeared cymbals and treble.
Is lossless audio worth it over Bluetooth?
Mostly not. Standard Bluetooth re-encodes audio with its own lossy codec, so a lossless stream is compressed again before it reaches wireless headphones. Lossless pays off with a wired connection and good headphones.
Does Spotify have lossless audio?
Yes, on Premium. Spotify's support page lists a Lossless setting of up to 24-bit/44.1 kHz FLAC on desktop, mobile and tablet for Premium users. Free users can choose up to High, about 160 kbps.
What audio quality does Melodius stream?
Standard streaming quality from the provider the track comes from. There is no quality selector and no lossless option. Melodius focuses on playback tools instead: a 10-band equalizer, volume normalization, a loudness leveler and crossfade.