Volume Normalization: Why Some Songs Play Louder
Shuffle a playlist that spans thirty years and you will reach for the volume every few songs. That is not your imagination, and it is not your headphones: it is how the music was mastered.
From the 1990s into the 2010s, records were mastered progressively louder, a trend usually called the loudness war. Compression and limiting raised the average level so a track would stand out on radio and in shops. Every release still had the same maximum peak; what changed was how much of the time it sat near that peak. Put a 1985 ballad next to a 2008 rock single and the second one is dramatically louder at the same volume setting.
Peak level and perceived loudness are different things
A track's peak is its single loudest sample. Perceived loudness depends on the average energy over time, weighted for how sensitive the ear is to each frequency. Two songs can share a peak and differ in loudness by ten decibels. Normalizing to the peak therefore does almost nothing; normalizing to perceived loudness is what evens playlists out.
- LUFS
- Loudness Units relative to Full Scale. A standard way to measure perceived loudness over a whole track, defined in broadcast standards. More negative means quieter: −14 LUFS is quieter than −9 LUFS.
- Loudness normalization
- Turning each track up or down so its measured loudness lands on a target. The music is not compressed or altered; only its overall level changes, unless the player has to limit peaks to fit.
- Track mode and album mode
- Track mode levels every song individually. Album mode applies one adjustment to a whole album, so a deliberately quiet interlude stays quieter than the song after it.
How Spotify does it
Spotify documents its targets. By default it normalizes to −14 LUFS, and Premium listeners can choose Loud at −11 LUFS or Quiet at −19 LUFS. A whole album is normalized together when you play it as an album, while shuffled albums and mixed playlists are adjusted track by track. On the Loud setting, Spotify applies a limiter to prevent distortion on tracks that have to be turned up.
Other services use similar approaches with their own targets, and most let you switch it off. The details matter less than the principle: once normalization is on, a louder master no longer plays louder.
When to turn normalization off
- Albums meant to be heard in order, when your player only offers track-by-track levelling. Classical, jazz and many concept albums rely on contrast between movements or songs.
- DJ mixes and live recordings where level changes are part of the performance.
- When you are judging masters, comparing versions of a recording or setting up an equalizer by ear and want nothing else moving.
For everything else, and especially shuffle, mixed playlists and listening with other people, leave it on.
Normalization and loudness levelling are not the same
Normalization changes the level of a whole song. A loudness leveler, sometimes called night mode or dynamic range compression, changes levels within a song, lifting quiet passages and taming loud ones. That is useful on a noisy bus or late at night, and it does change the music, flattening the dynamics the mix was built on. Use it for the situation, not all the time.
How it works in Melodius
Melodius has both, and they are separate switches. Volume normalization is in Playback settings and is on by default. It measures loudness as the song plays and moves the level gradually towards a common target, within limits: it will lift a quiet track by at most 6 dB and lower a loud one by at most 9 dB. Because it measures as it plays rather than reading a value prepared in advance, the level of a very loud or very quiet song settles over its first few seconds.
The loudness leveler is with the equalizer in the sound settings. It is off by default and evens out loud and quiet parts within a song. Whenever either one, or any equalizer boost, raises the signal, a limiter switches on to stop peaks from clipping.
Frequently asked questions
Should volume normalization be on or off?
On for shuffle, mixed playlists and background listening, so every song plays at a similar loudness. Off for albums that rely on quiet and loud contrast if your player only levels track by track, and for DJ mixes or live recordings.
Does volume normalization reduce audio quality?
Normalization itself only changes the overall level of a track. Quality is affected only if a quiet track is raised so far that its peaks have to be limited, which players handle with a limiter. A loudness leveler is different: it compresses dynamics within a song.
What LUFS does Spotify normalize to?
Spotify documents −14 LUFS as the default, with Loud at −11 LUFS and Quiet at −19 LUFS available to Premium listeners. Albums are normalized as a whole when played as an album.
Where is volume normalization in Melodius?
In Playback settings, where it is on by default. On Android it is also in Settings, Sound, next to the equalizer and the loudness leveler.